Opinion

Why the Jackdaw lies matter

by | 21 Oct 2026

It has been clear for a long time that Jackdaw was going to be approved but it doesn't make it any better. It is not just the 35 million tonnes of carbon, it's that we have opened a door to a dangerous politics and we'll find it hard to close that door again.

It has been clear for some time that Shell was going to get its permission to drill baby drill. Labour was the last mainstream political party pretending to be in two minds about it. Corporate profits are the only thing that is non-negotiable in Britain.

The problem isn’t just that this has happened but how it has happened. It has happened based on dishonesty and a lack of morality and if you don’t know what happens to people who deal in dishonesty and lack of morality then let me give you the ‘punch a granny in the face’ rule. Here is how it goes.

No-one wants to punch grannies in the face. OK, some people want to punch grannies in the face but they can’t say it out loud because it is bad. OK, get someone else to say it, because then you can oppose it but offer a compromise. What if we just punch one granny in the face? It’s not ideal. In fact OK, it’s sort of utterly wrong. But if it prevents a worse thing happening…

What worse thing happening? The thing that wasn’t happening anyway. You have created the conditions in which a granny gets punched in the face and you’ve done it knowingly. Here’s the real kicker – punching grannies in the face is now something we do. It’s a fair compromise. Now we can save 100 grannies getting punched in the face by punching five in the face and saying it’s OK.

Because today when Labour stood up in Parliament, rather than lead the world away from destruction it just basically agreed with Kemi Badenoch (who is a 100 per cent climate change denier and the most extremist politician ever with a chance of becoming a prime minister of Britain).

Labour is OK with one granny being punched. It is no longer in a position to make a moral case against grannies being punched. It has lied for Shell (pumping this gas will not bring your bills down, it will not support a carbon transition, it will not slow down the decline of the North Sea oil industry and it will not increase our energy security). Now it can’t unlie.

So it has validated Badenoch’s lies. And it has opened the door for the Lib Dems who are now all in on the same lies. Just for now you understand; the official Lib Dem policy is ‘just this granny and no more grannies after that’. Yet I doubt this will be the last granny a Lib Dem punches in the face.

The real long and short of it is only one thing, one actually true thing – today there are 35 million tonnes of carbon dioxide going into the world’s atmosphere than there was yesterday

The SNP was already lying and I just want to go through its various lies to show you how morally bankrupt the party is. So first and above all, the SNP will now support the drilling of every drop of oil but also pretend it’s not a climate offender. And to goose that show it wants the foreign oil corporations to get a giant tax cut windfall to go along with their price gouging record global profits.

Having done everything Shell and BP wants (and more), it needs to sell this to its party conference so it promises a Norway-style oil fund. With the tax it doesn’t want to raise. But having told that lie to its members it needs a new lie for everyone in Scotland who cares about climate change, so now it wants the UK Government to spend the money on heat pumps.

That’s the money it doesn’t want to raise which it has already claimed for an oil fund that doesn’t exist. They’ve now spent that three times over. And how much is it? Probably zero. Because they’re all lying now, no-one is raising the point that by the time the tax breaks for drilling and decommissioning are included it is quite likely that this new development will raise no tax money at all.

But you know, that’s like arithmetic, and so nowhere near as important as corporate lobbying. So now everyone apart from the Greens are parroting the lie. And of course we know the Greens won’t get proper media coverage because the media coordinated its delegitimisation campaign a couple of weeks ago.

Meaning the BBC makes clear this is ‘everyone versus some climate activists’. That too is a lie since it omits everyone else, like scientists and insurance companies and all the people dying in heatwaves and floods.

So what does the public see now? There’s this granny being punched on TV and the politicians are all clapping so what have we learned from this? There are clearly occasions on which punching grannies is politically acceptable. So how long is the gap between that happening and a mainstream political leader calling for all the grannies to be punched in the face all the time?

It was just a few hours. And the party of the working people stood up to this onslaught on the nation’s grannies by saying… No, no, just some grannies. Last year the Labour Party opposed punching grannies and now it does not and that is the long and short of it.

Or no, it’s not. The real long and short of it is only one thing, one actually true thing – today there are 35 million tonnes of additional carbon dioxide going into the world’s atmosphere than there was yesterday. Even normally reasonable people like The Guardian’s Nils Pratley are outright lying about this.

No-one else in the world is going to reduce production as a result of this decision. It is offsetting nothing. It is not net neutral. It is 35 million tonnes of carbon dioxide going into the atmosphere. The efforts they’re all going to to get you to look at any other alternative narrative is all you need to know.

Frankly I hope the kids burn your conference centres to the ground

The lies roll off the oil industries corporate lobbying press uninterrupted. We ‘need’ oil and gas to decarbonise? No, we need it because we’re not decarbonising. Oil and gas does zero to reduce the need for oil and gas. Now they’ve added 35 million tonnes of carbon dioxide to the atmosphere they’re finally in a position to do some decarbonising?

In fact there are so many lies that float around this idea that decarbonisation is conditional to oil and gas and they’re all utterly untrue. Oil and gas matters to decarbonisation in exactly the way horseshoes do to the development of the internal combustion engine.

I’m not a climate purist, I’m a climate realist. And a realist isn’t a realist if they don’t listen to the science and observe the measured reality of what is happening to our world. A realist knows we’ve already done so much damage there is no more prevaricating. A realist knows there is no remaining oil and gas we can really afford to burn. It’s already too late. You have lived through all the accelerating extreme weather the rest of us have.,

And so I feel pretty sick today. Watching the knuckle-dragging Tories at The Scotsman gloating is not what I look forward to over breakfast. Hearing everyone trying to rationalise today as if it is not a giant setback which is going to lead to more and more and more setbacks is unbearable. You all know what you did.

We now know what Burnham’s Labour really is. We already knew what Swinney’s SNP is. And Kei Badenoch hasn’t been slow to let us know what her Tories are. And now, on oil and gas, they might as well be the same thing. That unity around this subject is so corrosively dangerous I don’t have the words. None of this is cost free.

If you want to put me straight on the joys of Scotland pumping oil, seriously, don’t email me, you will not get a reply. Really. I’m not interested. If you’re a politician for a party that supports expanding oil and gas extraction, well, you will pay a price. I promise you. You are all going to pay a very high political price.

And what do I hope it is? Frankly I hope the kids burn your conference centres to the ground. By the time everyone knows you were lying you’ll be in the corporate board room and they’ll be scrabbling around trying to find some way to live on a planet we destroyed for loose change.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This